Research Article |
Corresponding author: Elias Freyhof ( elifreyhof@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Thomas Schmitt
© 2024 Elias Freyhof, Emil Janke.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Freyhof E, Jantke E (2024) Introduced greenhouse-invertebrates in Potsdam and Berlin with a focus on ants (Hymenoptera, Formicidae) with eight new records for Europe, Germany or the Berlin-Brandenburg region. Contributions to Entomology 74(2): 235-248. https://doi.org/10.3897/contrib.entomol.74.e136784
|
Heated greenhouses are a hotspot for introduced species from warmer climates. We studied 24 greenhouses for their invertebrate fauna with a special focus on ants. Identifications were initialised by iNaturalist and its community, followed by literature, COI barcoding and consulting experts in some cases. We report 32 introduced species including eight new records at the regional, national or continental scale, four of which are ants. Technomyrmex difficilis and Solenopsis texana are recorded for the first time in Germany. Plagiolepis alluaudi and Technomyrmex vitiensis are new for Berlin and Brandenburg. Alepia cf. viatrix (Diptera, Psychodidae) is first recorded for continental Eurasia. Cryptotermes cavifrons (Blattodea, Kalotermitidae) and Geonemertes pelaensis (Hoplonemertea, Prosorhochmidae) are recorded the first time for Europe. An unidentified species of the genus Anisorhynchodemus (Tricladida, Geoplanidae) is recorded the first time for Germany. Here, we present records for 37 species (five of the ant species are native), all associated with pictures in iNaturalist. For 33 individuals of 20 species, we also provide COI sequence data supporting their identification. Furthermore, the comparison of greenhouse metadata with species composition showed that the introduced ant species are dependent on a high minimum temperature in the greenhouse.
Biological invasions, COI barcoding, greenhouse fauna, iNaturalist, introduced species, new records
The introduction of non-native species is a side effect of globalisation and the associated international trade of goods (
To create the (sub)tropical environment typical of heated greenhouses, soil and plant material have been imported from a wide range of tropical and subtropical countries and plants have also been exchanged amongst greenhouses. This results in a high potential for species not only to be introduced, but also to spread and to become established over time. The stable climatic conditions allow tropical species to build up populations and become abundant in greenhouses (
The aim of this study is to document non-native invertebrates in heated greenhouses in Berlin and Potsdam, with a particular focus on ants. Ants are amongst the most successful and damaging invaders worldwide (
The study examined six facilities (Fig.
Greenhouse | Size in m² | Usage | Minimum temperature in °C | Average air humidity in % | Insecticides or biological pest control use | Date of visit | Coordinates | Abbreviation of climatic units |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gärten der Welt (GW.), Balinese Garden (“Balinesischer Garten”) | 1200 | plant cultivation | 18 | 80 | Biological pest control: Ichneumonidae wasps two times a month | 13.11.2023 | 52°32.37'N, 13°34.656‘ E | / |
FEZ., Eco Island (“Ökoinsel”) | 300 | plant cultivation | 10 | 45 | insecticides: Ant bait boxes if needed Neudorff Loxiran https://www.neudorff.de/produkte/loxiran-ameisenkoederdose.html | 24.11.2023 | 52°27.7533'N, 13°33.075'E | / |
Botanical Garden Berlin (BGB.), house A | 1900 | plant cultivation | 19 | 55 | Biological pest control: Cryptolaemus montrouzieri, Anolis sagrei, Ichneumonidae, Eleutherodactylus coqui and more Insecticides: In winter, individual plants are sprayed with insecticides. If there are too many ants, they are controlled with gels. | 22.11.2023 | 52°27.395'N, 13°18.447'E | / |
BGB., house B | 170 | plant cultivation | 18 | 70 | as BGB. | 27.11.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.375'N, 13°18.467'E | B |
BGB., house C | 500 | plant cultivation | 17 | 70 | as BGB. | 27.11.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.365'N, 13°18.478'E | C |
BGB., house D | 135 | plant cultivation | 15 | 70 | as BGB. | 27.11.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.357'N, 13°18.462'E | D |
BGB., house E | 200 | plant cultivation | 17 | 58 | as BGB. | 27.11.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.350'N, 13°18.445'E | E |
BGB., house F | 370 | plant cultivation | 17 | 70 | as BGB. | 27.11.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.358'N, 13°18.437'E | F |
BGB., house G | 200 | plant cultivation | 17 | 50 | as BGB. | 27.11.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.365'N, 13°18.425'E | G |
BGB., house H/I | 570 | plant cultivation | 12 | 45 | as BGB. | 29.12.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.395'N, 13°18.395'E | H/I |
BGB., house K | 200 | plant cultivation | 6 | 60 | as BGB. | 29.12.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.408'N, 13°18.378'E | K |
BGB., house L | 135 | plant cultivation | 10 | 50 | as BGB. | 29.12.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.413'N, 13°18.395'E | L |
BGB., house M | 500 | plant cultivation | 10 | 45 | as BGB. | 29.12.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.422'N, 13°18.413'E | M |
BGB., house N | 170 | plant cultivation | 8 | 60 | as BGB. | 29.12.2023, 14.05.2024 | 52°27.413'N, 13°18.422'E | N |
BGB. Cultivation house GW.-02-Blü | 275 | plant cultivation | 19 | 50 | as BGB. | 09.01.2024 | 52°27.315'N, 13°18.485'E | O |
BGB. cultivation house 52°27.147'N, 13°18.677'E | 220 | plant cultivation | 18 | 60 | as BGB. | 09.01.2024 | 52°27.147'N, 13°18.676'E | P |
Biosphere Potsdam (BP.) | 5000 | show greenhouse | 19 | 94 | Biological pest control: Cryptolaemus montrouzieri, Ichneumonidae, Nematoda, Chalcidoidea Insecticides: Neudorff Loxiran Ameisenköderdosen: https://www.neudorff.de/produkte/loxiran-ameisenkoederdose.html https://www.unkrautvernichter-shop.de/IMIDASECT-Schabengel.html https://www.unkrautvernichter-shop.de/imidasect-ants.html | 16.01.2024, 17.01.24 | 52°25.112'N, 13°02.917'E | / |
Botanical Garden Potsdam (BGP.), Palmenhaus | 300 | plant cultivation | 14 | 60 | Biological pest control: multiple species Insecticides: Spruzit Pyritrin | 30.01.2024 | 52°24.219'N, 13°01.563'E | PH |
BGP., Epiphytenhaus | 220 | plant cultivation | 19 | 100 | as BGP. | 31.01.2024 | 52°24.219'N, 13°01.563'E | EH |
BGP. Nutzpflanzenhaus | 225 | plant cultivation | 18 | 70 | as BGP. | 01.02.2024 | 52°24.213'N, 13°01.540'E | NH |
BGP., Haus der tropischen Vielfalt | 225 | plant cultivation | 18 | 80 | as BGP. | 02.02.2024 | 52°24.215'N, 13°01.527'E | HTV |
BGP., Kakteenhaus | 190 | plant cultivation | 10 | 50 | as BGP. | 03.02.2024 | 52°24.215'N, 13°01.515'E | KH |
BGP., Victoriahaus | 315 | plant cultivation | 19 | 80 | as BGP. | 04.02.2024 | 52°24.227'N, 13°01.533'E | VH |
BGP., Farnhaus | 220 | plant cultivation | 16 | 80 | as BGP. | 05.02.2024 | 52°24'13.5"N, 13°01'33.2"E | FH |
The Pearson-correlation analysis was carried out in Excel (2024) to find out whether the number of introduced and native ant species and those of native species correlate with the minimum temperatures of the greenhouses.
Each greenhouse was searched manually for invertebrates. Loose objects, such as wood and stones, were turned over and the soil underneath was inspected. We also scanned the lower foliage. Ants were additionally lured with a bait of sugar-water or a mixture of fish oil, rum and honey (as recommended by Bernhard Seifert, pers. com.). The baits were placed on small (25 × 25 mm) plastic plates and placed approximately every four metres along the walkways throughout the greenhouses. After 30‒60 minutes, the baits were checked for ants. Table
Species | Recorded from | New record(s) | Native range | Invasiveness (ranked by antwiki.org) | Identification based on |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lasius emarginatus (Olivier, 1792) | BGB. (A, E, H/I, K, L, M, N), BGP. (VH, FH) | / | Native | / |
|
Lasius niger (Linnaeus, 1758) | BGB. (A, E, H/I, K, L, M, N), BGP. (PH, FH), FEZ. | / | Native | / |
|
Ponera coarctata (Latreille, 1802) | BGB. (K) | / | Native | / |
|
Solenopsis fugax (Latreille, 1798) | BGP. (PH) | / | Native | / | Seifert (pers. com.), barcoding, |
Tetramorium caespitum complex | BGP. (PH, KH), FEZ. | / | Native | / |
|
Hypoponera ergatandria (Forel, 1893) | BGP. (PH, VH), BP. | / | unknown | highly invasive (cosmopolitan) |
|
Plagiolepis alluaudi Emery, 1894 | BGB. (A, B, C, D, E, F, G, O, P), BGP. (EH) | Berlin & Brandenburg | Africa ( |
highly invasive (cosmopolitan) |
|
Solenopsis texana Emery 1895 | BP., GW. | Germany | the americans | Seifert (pers. com.), barcoding | |
Technomyrmex difficilis Forel, 1892 | BP. | Germany | Madagascan region ( |
highly invasive (cosmopolitan) | Seifert (pers. com.), |
Technomyrmex vitiensis Mann, 1921 | BGB. (A, B, C, D, O), BGP. (PH, EH, NH, HTV, VH, FH) | Berlin & Brandenburg | Southeast Asian region ( |
highly invasive (cosmopolitan) | Seifert (pers. com.), |
Tetramorium bicarinatum (Nylander, 1846) | BGB. (A, B, C) | / | Oriental region ( |
highly invasive (cosmopolitan) | Garcia and Fisher (2011), barcoding, iNat RG, iNat AI |
All species were photographed (Nikon D600 with macro lens, distance rings and tong flash) and a few individuals of each species were transferred to 90% ethanol. Georeferenced records were uploaded to the global reporting platform iNaturalist (www.inaturalist.org). All records are available on the iNaturalist profiles eliasfreyhof36614’s Profile iNaturalist and emilvus’s Profile iNaturalist. iNaturalist’s artificial intelligence (computer vision) suggested an initial taxonomic identification, which was then critically reviewed by us. The iNaturalist community either suggested alternative species identifications or confirmed ours, a process that was an additional step towards a valid identification. These identifications were made by both amateur and expert naturalists. At least two matching identifications or two-thirds of matching identifications were required to achieve ‘research grade’ at iNaturalist. Some species that were difficult to identify from a photograph were identified morphologically and/or genetically. Morphology was examined using binoculars and specialist literature (Table
Other introduced greenhouse fauna (see Material and methods for abbreviations).
Class | Order | Species | Recorded for | New record(s) | Native range | Identification based on |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Insecta | Orthoptera | Gryllodes sigillatus/supplicans | BGB. | / | South-western Asia (www.speciesfile.org 2024) | barcoding, iNat RG, iNat AI |
Insecta | Orthoptera | Tachycines asynamorus (Adelung, 1902) | FEZ., GW. | / | East Asia ( |
barcoding, iNat RG, iNat AI |
Insecta | Blattodea | Cryptotermes cavifrons Banks, 1906 | BP. | Europe | Florida ( |
barcoding, |
Insecta | Blattodea | Periplaneta australasiae (Fabricius, 1775) | BGB., BGP., BP. | / | Africa ( |
barcoding, iNat RG, iNat AI |
Insecta | Blattodea | Pycnoscelus surinamensis (Linnaeus, 1758) | BP. | / | Indo-Malaysia ( |
barcoding, iNat RG, iNat AI |
Insecta | Dermaptera | Euborellia arcanum Matzke & Kočárek, 2015 | BP. | / | unknown | barcoding, iNat RG, iNat AI |
Insecta | Coleoptera | Sitophilus oryzae A.Hustache, 1930 | BP. | / | likely Indian subcontinent ( |
barcoding, iNat AI |
Insecta | Diptera | Alepia cf. viatrix Jaume-Schinkel, Kvifte, Weele & Mengual, 2022 | BGP. | Continental Eurasia | Neotropics ( |
barcoding |
Arachnida | Araneae | Amaurobius ferox (Walckenaer, 1830) | BGB. | / | Mediterranean region ( |
iNat RG, iNat AI |
Arachnida | Araneae | Hasarius adansoni (Audouin, 1826) | BGB., BGP., BP., GW. | / | Africa (World Spider Catalogue 2017) | iNat RG, iNat AI |
Arachnida | Araneae | Holocnemus pluchei (Scopoli, 1763) | BGP. | / | Mediterranean region (World Spider Catalogue 2016) | iNat RG |
Arachnida | Araneae | Parasteatoda tepidariorum (C.L.Koch, 1841) | BGB., BGP., BP. | / | unknown | iNat RG, iNat AI |
Arachnida | Araneae | Pholcus phalangioides (Fuesslin, 1775) | BP. | / | Western Asia ( |
iNat RG, iNat AI |
Arachnida | Araneae | Uloborus plumipes Lucas, 1846 | BGP., BP. | / | Old World (World Spider Catalog 2020) | iNat RG, iNat AI |
Arachnida | Schizomida | Stenochrus portoricensis Chamberlin, 1922 | BP. | / | Southeast Asia ( |
barcoding, |
Diplopoda | Spirobolida | Leptogoniulus sorornus (Butler, 1876) | BP. | / | Southeast Asia ( |
Peter Decker (pers. com.), iNat RG, iNat AI |
Diplopoda | Polydesmida | Oxidus gracilis (C.L.Koch, 1847) | BGB., BGP., BP. | / | East Asia ( |
barcoding, iNat RG, iNat AI |
Malacostraca | Amphipoda | Talitroidea | BGP. | / | iNat: one expert opinion | |
Malacostraca | Isopoda | Porcellio dilatatus Brandt, 1831 | BGP. | / | Southwest Europe ( |
Andreas Allspach (pers. com.), iNat RG, iNat AI |
Gastropoda | Stylommatophora | Ambigolimax valentianus (A.Férussac, 1821) | BGB., BGP. | / | Southwest Europe (www.naturportal-suedwest.de 2024) | Carsten Renker (pers. com.), iNat RG, iNat AI |
Gastropoda | Stylommatophora | Hygromia cinctella (Draparnaud, 1801) | BGB. | / | Italy and surrounding regions ( |
Carsten Renker (pers. com.), iNat RG, iNat AI |
Gastropoda | Sorbebeoconcha | Melanoides tuberculata (O.F.Müller, 1774) | BP. | / | unknown | Carsten Renker (pers. com.), iNat RG, iNat AI |
Gastropoda | Pulmonata | Physella acuta (Draparnaud, 1805) | BGP. | / | North America ( |
Carsten Renker (pers. com.), iNat RG, iNat AI |
Gastropoda | Stylommatophora | Subulina cf. octona (Bruguière, 1789) | BGP., BP. | / | Caribbean ( |
Carsten Renker (pers. com.) |
Hoplonemertea | Monostilifera | Geonemertes pelaensis Semper, 1863 | BP. | Europe | Indopacific region ( |
Leigh Winsor (pers. com.), barcoding, iNat RG, iNat AI |
Turbellaria | Tricladida | Anisorhynchodemus sp. | BP. | Germany | unknown | Leigh Winsor (pers. com.), iNat RG, iNat AI |
DNA was extracted from whole samples, leg or femur muscle tissue (stored in ethanol) using sterilised tweezers. After allowing the ethanol to evaporate, DNA was extracted using a Chelex extraction protocol (modified from
The barcoding fragment of the mitochondrial COI gene was amplified using Qiagen DNA polymerase (QIAGEN Multiplex PCR Plus Kit, Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) at a concentration of 50% of the total reaction volume and a concentration of 33% of each primer. Primers LCO_1490 and HCO_2198 (
Species | Sample ID | Collection Date | Recorded from | Coordinates (Lat, Lon) | Bold ID | Highest similarity | Possible species COI |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cryptotermes cavifrons | DEI-Hemimetabola100424 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR001-24 | 99.85% to TMTER440-15 (Cryptotermes cavifrons) | / |
Tetramorium bicarinatum | DEI-GISHym5391 | 22.11.2023 | BGB. | 52.4564, 13.3076 | GBAR002-24 | 100% to ASANA722-06 (Tetramorium bicarinatum) | / |
Tetramorium bicarinatum | DEI-GISHym5392 | 22.11.2023 | BGB. | 52.4564, 13.3076 | GBAR003-24 | 100% to ASANA722-06 (Tetramorium bicarinatum) | / |
Stenochrus portoricensis | SMNG_24/67178/1 | 17.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR004-24 | 100% to GACO1420-19 (Stenochrus portoricensis) | / |
Stenochrus portoricensis | SMNG_24/67178/2 | 17.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR005-24 | 100% to GACO1420-19 (Stenochrus portoricensis) | / |
Technomyrmex difficilis | DEI-GISHym5393 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR006-24 | 100% to ASANA512-06 (Technomyrmex difficilis) | / |
Sitophilus oryzae | SDEI-Coleoptera304561 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR007-24 | 100% to CICRP053-15 (Sitophilus oryzae) | / |
Technomyrmex vitiensis | DEI-GISHym5394 | 22.11.2023 | BGB. | 52.4564, 13.3076 | GBAR008-24 | 100% to LEFIJ12092-20 (Technomyrmex vitiensis) | / |
Technomyrmex vitiensis | DEI-GISHym5395 | 22.11.2023 | BGB. | 52.4564, 13.3076 | GBAR009-24 | 100% to LEFIJ12092-20 (Technomyrmex vitiensis) | / |
Plagiolepis alluaudi | DEI-GISHym5396 | 21.11.2023 | BGB. | 52.4564, 13.3076 | GBAR010-24 | 99.84% to ASAMZ391-07 (Plagiolepis alluaudi) | P. alluaudi, Nylanderia madagascarensis |
Hypoponera ergatandria | DEI-GISHym5397 | 30.01.2024 | BGP. | 52.4038, 13.0254 | GBAR011-24 | 100% to NODRY624-15 (Hypoponera ergatandria) | H. punctatissima, H. ergatandria |
Hypoponera ergatandria | DEI-GISHym5398 | 30.01.2024 | BGP. | 52.4038, 13.0254 | GBAR012-24 | 100% to NODRY624-15 (Hypoponera ergatandria) | H. punctatissima, H. ergatandria |
Ponera coarctata | DEI-GISHym5399 | 29.12.2023 | BGB. | 52.4568, 13.3063 | GBAR013-24 | 100% to ANTBG104-11 (Ponera coarctata) | P. coarctata, P. testacea |
Lasius emarginatus | DEI-GISHym5400 | 30.01.2024 | BGP. | 52.4037, 13.0255 | GBAR014-24 | 100% to NOANT006-12 (Lasius niger) | L. niger, L. platythorax, L. brunneus, L. paralienus, L. emarginatus |
Lasius emarginatus | DEI-GISHym5401 | 30.01.2024 | BGP. | 52.4037, 13.0255 | GBAR015-24 | 100% to NOANT006-12 (Lasius niger) | L. niger, L. platythorax, L. brunneus, L. paralienus, L. emarginatus |
Tachycines asynamorus | DEI-Hemimetabola100425 | 14.11.2023 | GW. | 52.5395, 13.5777 | GBAR016-24 | 100% to GBORT531-14 (Tachycines asynamorus) | / |
Periplaneta australasiae | DEI-Hemimetabola100426 | 22.11.2023 | BGB. | 52.4564, 13.3076 | GBAR017-24 | 100% to VAQT477-09 (Periplaneta australasiae) | / |
Pycnoscelus surinamensis | DEI-Hemimetabola100427 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR018-24 | 100% to TTSOW223-10 (Pycnoscelus surinamensis) | / |
Euborellia arcanum | DEI-Hemimetabola100428 | 17.01.2023 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR019-24 | 100% to GBMND6588-21 (Euborellia arcanum) | / |
Gryllodes sigillatus/supplicans | DEI-Hemimetabola100429 | 14.05.2024 | BGB. | 52.4565, 13.3066 | GBAR020-24 | 99.08% to MAORT859-12 (Gryllodes supplicans) | G. sigillatus, G. supplicans |
Oxidus gracilis | VNR_021924 | 29.12.2023 | BGB. | 52.4568, 13.3063 | GBAR021-24 | 100% to MYRUS048-09 (Oxidus gracilis) | / |
Geonemertes pelaensis | DEI-Hemimetabola100430 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR022-24 | 100% to GBSP16798-19 (Geonemertes pelaensis) | / |
Plagiolepis alluaudi | DEI-GISHym5402 | 09.01.2024 | BGB. | 52.4524, 13.3113 | GBAR023-24 | 100% to ASAMZ391-07 (Plagiolepis alluaudi) | P. alluaudi, Nylanderia madagascarensis |
Alepia cf. viatrix | DEI-Hemimetabola100431 | 30.01.2024 | BGP. | 52.4035, 13.0256 | GBAR024-24 | 100% to ASMII2842-22 (Alepia viatrix) | / |
Solenopsis texana | DEI-GISHym5403 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR025-24 | 100% to ASPNA1425-10 (Solenopsis saudiensis) | / |
Solenopsis texana | DEI-GISHym5404 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR026-24 | 100% to ASPNA1425-10 (Solenopsis saudiensis) | / |
Solenopsis texana | DEI-GISHym5405 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR027-24 | 100% to ASPNA1425-10 (Solenopsis saudiensis) | / |
Solenopsis texana | DEI-GISHym5406 | 14.11.2023 | GW. | 52.5395, 13.5777 | GBAR028-24 | 100% to ASPNA1425-10 (Solenopsis saudiensis) | / |
Solenopsis texana | DEI-GISHym5407 | 14.11.2023 | GW. | 52.5395, 13.5777 | GBAR029-24 | 100% to ASPNA1425-10 (Solenopsis saudiensis) | / |
Solenopsis texana | DEI-GISHym5408 | 14.11.2023 | GW. | 52.5395, 13.5777 | GBAR030-24 | 100% to ASPNA1425-10 (Solenopsis saudiensis) | / |
Technomyrmex difficilis | DEI-GISHym5409 | 16.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | GBAR031-24 | 100% to ASANA512-06 (Technomyrmex difficilis) | / |
Solenopsis fugax | DEI-GISHym5410 | 30.01.2024 | BGP. | 52.4036, 13.0261 | GBAR032-24 | 100% to ANTBG284-11 (Solenopsis fugax) | / |
Technomyrmex vitiensis | DEI-GISHym5411 | 30.01.2024 | BGP. | 52.4036, 13.0261 | GBAR033-24 | 100% to LEFIJ12092-20 (Technomyrmex vitiensis) | / |
Tetramorium caespitum complex | DEI-GISHym5412 | 22.11.2023 | BGB. | 52.4036, 13.0261 | / | / | / |
Lasius niger | DEI-GISHym5413 | 22.11.2023 | BGB. | 52.4564, 13.3076 | / | / | / |
Leptogoniulus sorornus | VNR_021982 | 17.01.2024 | BP. | 52.4185, 13.0486 | / | / | / |
BGB: Botanical Garden Berlin, BGP: Botanical Garden Potsdam, BP: Biosphere Potsdam, GW: Gärten der Welt, FEZ: FEZ. Ökoinsel greenhouse.
A total of 32 introduced species were found in the five institutions. Insects are the largest taxonomic group with 14 species, including six species of ants, one species of termites, two cockroaches, two Orthoptera, one earwig, one weevil and one drainfly species. Seven species belong to spiders and, except for one species of Schizomida, all belong to the order Araneae. There were also six species of snails, two species of millipedes, one species of isopods, one species of amphipods, one species of terrestrial planaria and one species of terrestrial nemertine (Tables
From these, we report eight species for the first time at the regional, national or continental scale, i.e. we found no published or unpublished records:
iNaturalist (based on AI and/or community identifications) correctly identified 31 out of a total of 37 native and non-native species (83.8%). Of the eight new records, iNaturalist was able to identify five species. Twenty of the species were successfully barcoded. The attempt to barcode three additional species failed and the rest of the species were only photographed. In 13 cases, specialist literature was used for morphological identification. Of the total 37 species, 14 species were identified by experts (Tables
Correlation of minimal greenhouse temperatures with ant species numbers supports that the number of introduced species is dependent on high minimum temperatures, with the Pearson-correlation being significantly positive (r = 0.856; p < 0.01). For the native species, the correlation was negative, but not significant (r = -0.581; p = 0.078). Thus, native species occurred at almost all minimum temperatures (nine of the ten possible), while introduced species were not found in climatic units with a minimum temperature of 13 °C or less (Fig.
We found no introduced ant species in climatic units with minimum temperatures lower than 14 °C and the number of introduced species correlates positively with higher minimum temperatures. Our study shows that minimum temperature limits the colonisation success of introduced species (Fig.
iNaturalist provides an efficient, global method of species identification, with its AI trained on millions of images and currently covering 93,369 species. It excels at identifying common species with distinctive characters, but struggles with cryptic species such as ants. Community identifications are a good complement to AI because many biologists and professionals, together with amateur naturalists, can make a solid identification, if good photographs with the relevant features are provided. iNaturalist also connected us to international experts who helped in identifications allowing us to identify several taxa. For example, we got to know the experts Sean Birk, Bek Craig and Leigh Winsor through iNaturalist. However, taxonomic groups with small specialist communities often go unidentified. We faced this challenge with snails. While iNaturalist is a good starting point, it was not the only method used for difficult-to-identify species.
Where samples were collected, identification was possible through literature and/or COI barcoding. Both methods require special materials, specific knowledge and more time. However, these methods can provide very accurate identifications in many cases. Morphology-based literature requires matching keys or descriptions, which can be difficult to find for introduced species that can come from anywhere in the world. COI barcoding is more universal, but has the problem that not every individual can be identified to species level. For some species, there are few or no reference sequences in the database, which can lead to errors. At least one of these two methods was preferred by us to obtain a reliable identification of the more difficult-to-identify species.
The next method used was expert identification, which was an additional step, if one of the other methods did not work, was not possible or was not accurate enough. This method can provide a very reliable identification without a lot of knowledge and material. However, it requires contact with experts and some time. We also asked experts when only photos were taken and iNaturalist did not provide reliable identifications.
The next part of the discussion deals with the species which, as far as we could find out, are new records at the regional or even continental scale (Tables
(Fig.
This species of thief ant is extremely small (about 1.2 mm) and golden yellow in colour. Its native range should be the Americas, where it has been found in Canada, the USA, Mexico, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Panama, Colombia and Brazil. It has been introduced into greenhouses in Europe, including Norway and Germany (https://www.antwiki.org; (
(Fig.
This species is a 3.5‒4.0 mm long, black ant native to the Madagascar region (
Technomyrmex difficilis Photo from AntWeb (www.antweb.org); photographer: April Nobile.
The reproduction and caste system of T. difficilis is quite peculiar. After the death of the primary queen, ergatoid males and intercastes appear in the nest. The intercastes can make up almost half of the colony (
(Fig.
This species is a 3.5‒4.0 mm long, black ant, native to Southeast Asia (
Technomyrmex vitiensis Photo from AntWeb (www.antweb.org); photographer: April Nobile.
(Fig.
A very small (1.5 mm) yellow ant native to Africa (
Plagiolepis alluaudi Photo from AntWeb (www.antweb.org); photographer: April Nobile.
(Fig.
This dry-wood termite species is native to Florida (
(Fig.
This species of drainflies (Diptera, Psychodidae) is expected to be native to the Neotropics as all other species of the genus Alepia occur there (
(Fig.
A species of terrestrial nemertines (Hoplonemertea, Prosorhochmidae), which is probably native to the Indopacific Region (
(Fig.
A species of terrestrial flatworms of which the native range is unknown. The genus has been introduced to Florida, the Caribbean, the Madagascar region, Sri Lanka, Southeast Asia and Oceania (
The many new records for Berlin, Brandenburg, Germany and even at the continental scale demonstrate how poorly the faunas of greenhouses are known. While most of the tropical species recorded are unlikely to survive in the wild in Germany, they might be transported from our greenhouses to others, potentially reaching suitable climatic conditions along this road. It is not the aim of this study to speculate about the effect of invasive species. However, our findings highlight the immense knowledge gap of the greenhouse invertebrates. Furthermore, this study also shows how many different introduced taxonomic groups can be identified by a combination of the iNaturalist AI, its expert community and barcodes available from BOLD. Both open-access resources enabled the identification of most, but not all, of our species. Obviously, as biodiversity remains imperfectly described, many species complexes are awaiting their taxonomic revisions, making it actually impossible to identify some to the species level.
Indeed, we highly encourage other students, citizen scientists and experts to study greenhouse faunas as well as to publish their records. During our work, we came into contact with several citizen scientists, who told us that they have already seen particular species in greenhouses, but never found it worthwhile to publish these data. Nowadays, it is quite simple to publish single-species records through iNaturalist and other smartphone-based identification tools. To encourage citizen scientists to record greenhouse species, we set up an iNaturalist Project called “Greenhouse fauna of Europe”.
We thank the staff of the greenhouses who allowed us to collect, to take photos of the greenhouse fauna, gave us information about the greenhouses or even sent us ant samples: BGB (Henrike Wilke); BGP (Ingo Kallmeyer, Michael Burkart); BP (Rosita Meyer, Kristina Hasselmann); GW (Peter Moede); FEZ (Beate Butz). We would also like to thank the team and some students of the Deutsches Entomologisches Institut Senckenberg. Many thanks to Eva Kleibusch, who taught us the steps of barcoding and other genetic tasks. Lara-Sophie Dey complemented this study with her genetic expertise. Thanks also to Stephan Blank for solving all sorts of problems. Christian Kutzscher showed how to prepare ants in a sensible way. Arne Köhler showed how to create and edit figures. Emilia Kramm helped a lot with the lab work, technical issues and the map. Nura Alaya helped to collect a missing sample. We are also grateful to the experts who helped with species identification: ants (Bernhard Seifert, Senckenberg Natural History Museum Görlitz (Germany)); snails (Carsten Renker, Mainz Natural History Museum); centipedes (Peter Decker, Senckenberg Natural History Museum Görlitz (Germany)); land planarians and terrestrial nemertines (Leigh Winsor, James Cook University (Australia); Schizomida (Sean Birk Bek Craig Aarhus University (Denmark)); Isopoda (Andreas Allspach, Senckenberg Research Institute and Natural History Museum Frankfurt (Germany)).